data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b375f/b375f9682f42cdfe196cac26bf280c7b72375868" alt=""
Meh. I didn't love this book. For me it was definitely not "compulsively readable". I kind of had to force myself to finish. I have a hard time reading a book when I can't connect with any of the characters. The novel is split into two parallel stories. You'll read a couple of chapters about David & his family, and then you'll read a couple of chapters about Caroline and the daughter that David gave away. Over the years, David's lie tears his family apart. The whole story of his family is depressing and frustrating... all of this pain & separation caused by his split-second decision and the lie he tells to cover it up. I just want to grab him by the neck and say "TELL THE TRUTH!". Caroline's story was much more interesting to me. I enjoyed reading about her struggles & triumphs raising the daughter with Down syndrome. The ending was only slightly satisfying.
Overall I thought the book was depressing and frustrating, though well written. It wasn't really my cup of tea. But hey, if it sounds interesting to you, knock yourself out! I have a copy I would gladly lend {give} to you!
5 comments:
I read this last fall and felt exactly the same way. It was really forgettable, and not really that great of a story for me. I wanted David and his wife to go to counseling!
I love Marrianne's comment. I agree, it was hard to connect with the character's because I would have never given my child away. But I did think the writing was excellent. And the scandal was entertaining. Good review.
I think it was Lifetime who did a film bu the same title? Loved the movie, which is odd when the book isn't so hot. You might want to try the movie...
I remember reading this and loving it until the part where the parents have affairs. It didn't feel right. I saw the last half of the movie and actually liked the movie better (gasp!)
so many people have said the movie was good. i'm going to have to watch it.
Post a Comment